|
My research history can be summarized in a number of steps,
which have led to the design and then further development
of the population synthesis code StarTrack.
The code at the present time is a state-of-the-art tool targeted for studies
of binaries containing compact objects: black holes, neutron stars
and white dwarfs.
At first I focused on studies of binaries with white dwarf accretors, in
particular cataclysmic variables and symbiotic stars.
In the next step I investigated the black holes and heavy neutron stars in
binary configurations that may possibly be connected to short Gamma-ray
burst progenitors.
This naturally led to binary compact objects, and calculation of their
physical properties and merger rates. Since the binary compact objects
are the most promising candidates for ground-based gravitational-wave
detectors I was invited to join the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave
Observatory (LIGO) scientific collaboration. Eventually, my interests
shifted to X-ray binaries. I have customized the most recent theoretical
developments connected to formation and evolution of X-ray binaries
for the population synthesis method.
At present, StarTrack is applied to the analysis of Chandra
observations of Galactic and extragalactic point X-ray sources.
Finally, I am also leading the studies of: Type Ia SN progenitors;
gravitational radiation sources for the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna
(LISA) observatory; and research on the formation and evolution of
black holes in cluster environments.
GENERAL OVERVIEW
- Achievements
The StarTrack population synthesis code was already widely
recognized in the community (∼ 100 citations on the first code
description paper [28]) and was successfully used in a number of
studies (≥ 30 refereed publications). Additionally, over the last
couple of years, the code has undergone major revisions and updates [1],
and now StarTrack is one of the best population synthesis codes on the
market. The results based on the StarTrack calculations have attracted
attention at many international meetings. Besides a number of contributed
talks, I was invited to review extragalactic X-ray binary modeling at an AAS
meeting, and twice (LIGO and LISA targeted workshops) to review double
compact object modeling at the Aspen Center for Physics. Also, several
colaborations have been initiated following various presentations of
StarTrack results. These include: studies of nearby starburst galaxies with
A.Zezas (Harvard-Smithsonian CfA); research on early Universe metal-free
stars and their potential role in context of Gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) and
gravitational radiation (GR) sources with C.Fryer and A.Heger (Los Alamos
National Lab.) or LISA-related projects with M.Benacquista (Univ.of
Montana) and S.Larson (Penn State). Although the code was primarily
developed to study compact objects: white dwarfs (WDs), neutron stars
(NSs) and black holes (BHs), its design and flexibility allow for
research in very different areas, which are in a broad sense connected to
stellar evolution.
- Education/Teaching
I began working with students 3 years ago. During my stay
at Northwestern I helped with the undergraduate projects supervised
by the Theory group faculty [5,6,10,19]. Currently, I am independently
advising a student who is finishing his Master degree thesis at Warsaw
Univ. (A.Sadowski; [4,22]) and a student who is working toward her
Ph.D. at New Mexico State Univ. (A.Ruiter; [2,3,8]). Also, I have
just started advising two undergrads on smaller research projects.
StarTrack is an ideal research tool for students (both on under- and
graduate levels) to conduct their own research. Once acquainted with the
code, I usually start students on advanced science projects. Along the
way they learn about stellar evolution, physics of compact objects and
additionally they acquire experience in massive computations, modeling
and data processing.
Recently, we have recognized the need to update graduate students in our
department on programming/computational skills. In the spring semester
2006 I will be teaching a course on computational astrophysics (ASTR698;
for syllabus see my Teaching page).
I am also interested in teaching undergraduate level courses (like
Introduction to Astronomy) to attract the best students from other related
departments (like physics, engineering, math) for short research projects
in astrophysics. Such an early selection offers a good chance of getting
the best (and tested) prospective students for graduate programs.
- Future Perspectives
I am planning to form an independent group working in the general area
of theoretical astrophysics of compact objects, high-energies and stellar
evolution. Of course, such a group will strongly interact with other
faculty members and their teams. I am very interested to work with
observers who have access to or collect data on binaries with white dwarfs,
neutron stars and black holes. Additionally I also seek a
direct research contact/interaction with theorists working in GRB and GR
fields.
I have already made the first steps toward creating an initial group. As
indicated above there are several students working on various projects
with me. I was also successful in securing extra funds in the form of research
grants (see my CV) to support both students and the research we carry out.
In the near future (next NSF cycle) I plan to apply for larger funds that
would allow me to expand the group with new members (e.g., a post-doc).
Also, since population synthesis modeling requires substantial computer
power, I plan to secure funds for development and maintenance of a small
computer cluster (32 or 64 processors).
In the following I describe my past and current research in a greater
detail. Some of the near future plans are also outlined. However, I
usually catch opportunities of research as they appear in the field, so it
is indeed very hard to predict precisely what I will be working on in the
years to come. Please, note the varied range of topics covered in my
publications, along with a general drift of expanding interests with
passing years.
CATACLYSMIC/SYMBIOTIC STARS
I began work on symbiotic stars with my Master Degree thesis:
``Light curve analysis of symbiotic stars''. The work included collection of
archival data, period estimation, and light curve synthesis for several
symbiotics. Careful study of T CrB light curves revealed that the hot
component of this system is a massive WD and not a main sequence star, and
solved the long standing argument about its nature [39].
Later, I prepared A Catalog of Symbiotic Stars [34].
This new catalog had been long-awaited as many new symbiotic stars
were discovered and a wealth of new data had been collected since 1986,
when the preceding catalog was published.
As a byproduct of this work we have found new orbital periods and estimated
binary parameters for two symbiotic stars: FN Sgr [12] and AE Ara.
I have also undertaken a study of a supersoft X-ray prototype and
cataclysmic variable V Sge, a quizzical system, for which many
different models were proposed throughout the years.
We have reanalyzed the old and new light curves together with spectroscopic
data showing inconsistencies of some other proposed models and attempted to
build a self-consistent picture for this binary and explain its behavior [32].
GAMMA-RAY BURSTS
In 1998, I started a project on binary population synthesis in
context of GRBs. First, I have constructed a simple code to evolve
massive stars and generate NS-NS/BH-NS binaries.
These systems were suggested as progenitors of short-duration GRBs.
The studies were set to check if the distribution of merger sites of
these systems may be reconciled with observed GRB sites in respect to
their host galaxies.
In this first approach we have also studied the influence of different
evolutionary parameters on the population of potential GRB progenitors
[38,36].
Later on, I created the first version of StarTrack and
results of population synthesis were combined with star formation
history and a cosmological model to calculate the change of the GRB
rates with redshift. Comparison of my predictions has allowed me to
put an upper limit of ∼ 4 degrees on GRB collimation.
Comparison of merger sites (with respect to their host galaxies) of
various proposed binary models has allowed me to exclude them as possible
long-duration GRB progenitors, with the exception of helium mergers [30]
which was later confirmed by the connection of long GRBs with SNe of
massive stars.
However, for short GRBs the mergers of compact objects are still the
most preferable model. Contrary to previous predictions, I found
that the majority of NS-NS binaries are expected to merge within their host
galaxies. Previous studies have neglected final evolutionary stages of
progenitor systems, and in particular the last mass transfer episode
driven by the He-rich donor (additional orbital shrinkage). Inclusion of
this effect led to the formation of a very short-lived NS-NS, which do
not live long enough to escape their host galaxies, despite their large
center-of-mass velocities [33,27,24].
The corresponding observational afterglow characteristics of the systems
merging within the host galaxies were then computed for the StarTrack
models [29]. It is interesting to note that now the SWIFT team (e.g., Fox
et al. 2005, Nature 437, 845) was able to locate a short GRB (which was
connected to NS-NS merger) within its host Galaxy. I have obtained
exactly the same result on theoretical grounds with the StarTrack
calculation, which at that time was rather controversial and in clear
contradiction with other findings.
GRAVITATIONAL WAVE SOURCES
Mergers of NS-NS, BH-NS and BH-BH are expected to be the most promising
candidates for ground-based gravitational wave observatories such as
LIGO or VIRGO. I have investigated binary evolution leading to
the formation of double compact objects. This led me to recognize
new channels for NS-NS formation [33,27]. Distinctive physical properties for
the new group of NS-NS were predicted (short lifetimes, high contribution
of non-recycled pulsars), and the increase correction factors were
suggested for the rate estimates based on the observed sample of NS-NS.
I have preformed a comprehensive study of compact object binaries with the
use of StarTrack, in which special care was given to population
method uncertainties (over 30 models investigated). A conclusion was reached
that a successful detection is not expected during the initial LIGO
stage (current status), but it is very likely during the advanced stage
(∼ 2009). I also showed that the results of StarTrack are in
agreement with the most recent observationally based NS-NS merger rate
estimates. The results are of importance for groups performing
gravitational-wave signal and hydro-dynamical merger calculations, e.g.,
they were used in the LIGO project [40,41,42,43,44,45,46,47,48].
I have aimed a number of studies to assess the observational
characteristics of sources for a given detector. Predictions of chirp masses
of merging binaries have been made. My calculations have shown that despite the
overall dominance of NS-NS binaries, BH-BH systems will be much easier to
detect due to their higher chirp masses. Realistic NS/BH mass distributions
and the change of the merger rate with redshift and other cosmological
parameters were taken into account.
I also made first attempts to predict what could be learned from the
initial GR observations. Moreover, it was shown that some parameters describing
the uncertain evolutionary processes may be constrained with only several
tens of detections [25,21,18] and also a non-uniform distribution
of galaxies within a sampled volume was taken into account [19].
X-RAY BINARIES
My recent research involves studies of the X-ray binaries (XRBs), and it
reflects the wealth of public Chandra and XMM Newton X-ray
observations available for theoretical analysis. Several projects are
already finished, several others are being conducted.
Recent RXTE and Chandra discoveries of low-mass X-ray
binaries with ultra-short orbital periods have initiated
theoretical work on the origins of these peculiar systems.
Using the StarTrack code I analyzed the formation and evolution of
X-ray ultracompact binaries (UCBs) in the Galactic field.
The relative number of UCBs with a NS or a BH accretor populating our
Galaxy was predicted. I demonstrated that standard
evolutionary scenarios involving primordial binaries can be
sufficient to produce the UCBs in the Galactic field without
requiring additional dynamical processes associated with the dense
cluster environments. In contrast to previous studies it was found
that the majority of the UCB progenitors are formed through the accretion
induced collapse of the heavy ONeMg WD to a NS. The most resent results
on the accretion physics and mass accumulation were used to obtain this
result [16].
I constructed the first synthetic XRB populations for direct comparison
with the X-ray luminosity functions (XLFs). I also carried out the first,
and successful, comparison with Chandra observations of a nearby
starburst galaxy NGC~1569. A self-consistent model of XRB which incorporated
the most recent advances in the field was created. Then the main goal was to
examine whether it is possible to reproduce the XLF shape with the
StarTrack models (and test their validity), given the current knowledge
for the star-formation history of this galaxy.
It was found that, for typical binary evolution parameters, it is indeed
possible to closely match the observed XLF shape. The robust match
is achieved for a hybrid synthetic population consisting of the young and
old stars formed in two starbursts, in agreement with HST observations of
NGC~1569. In view of this encouraging first step, I have discussed the
implications of XRB models and their potential as tools to study binary
populations in other galaxies [15].
Recent deep Chandra surveys of the Galactic center region have
revealed the existence of a low luminosity hard X-ray point source population.
It has been proposed that a majority of these sources can be explained by
a population of a neutron star fed by a stellar wind of a main sequence companion.
In my investigation, a population synthesis study of the Galactic center region
has been carried out, and it was found that transient systems in quiescence,
composed of low mass WDs transferring matter via Roche lobe overflow to their
NS/BH companions dominate over wind-fed XRBs [14].
However, I also found that the populations of wind-fed XRBs and quiescent
transients are not large enough to explain the bulk of observed faint
X-ray sources in the Galactic center (∼ 2000; Muno et al. 2003, ApJ 509,
225). The StarTrack X-ray model was expanded to include cataclysmic
variables (CVs), and the population synthesis of the Galactic center was
repeated. The first pilot study [2] shows that indeed a subpopulation
of the brightest CVs (intermediate polars) may explain both the number and
luminosities of the faint Galactic center sources.
I have undertaken a comprehensive, long-term theoretical study of XRB
populations, targeting point sources in different stellar environments
(starburst, spiral and elliptical galaxies). The existing and new
Chandra observations are being used for comparison to my
theoretical models with the aim of deriving constraints on the formation
and evolution of various types of X-ray binary systems in order to reveal
and understand the underlying X-ray binary populations formed in different
stellar environments. Among others the high-mass X-ray binaries, low-mass
X-ray binaries, ultra-luminous X-ray sources, CVs and pulsars are included
in the studies. A population synthesis method, based on statistical analysis
concepts of large stellar ensembles, is used and is perfectly suited for
the task.
There are two major steps in the project. The initial step is to use the
available X-ray data for the model calibration, for the first time, of the
various subclasses of X-ray binary systems. This calibration will impose
new constraints on the binary evolution leading to the X-ray phases and
will provide insights on the main physical processes important for the X-ray
binary systems. The second step is to use the X-ray binary calibrated code
to constrain the stellar environments in different galaxies with observed
point source populations. This will yield information on the
SF histories, initial mass functions, content of current X-ray populations
and compositions of stars in other galaxies.
OTHER ONGOING PROJECTS
I recently started studies of Type Ia SNe and their unknown
origins. Type Ia SNe are the prime distance indicators used in a modern cosmology,
and it is crucial to understand their origin. Connecting Type Ia SNe to one or
several different progenitors may resolve the Type Ia SN standard candle
issue. Using the most recent observations of delay times of Type Ia SNe up to
high redshifts, we were able to demonstrate that most likely Type Ia SNe originate
from a single progenitor: merger of two carbon oxygen white dwarfs,
confirming the validity of Type Ia SN standard candle assumption. First results
were already communicated [8].
Close WD-WD binaries are predicted to be the source of confusion noise
for the LISA, a low frequency gravitational radiation detector.
It is very important to understand
the characteristic level of this noise (which will hinder a detection of
other important sources, like extreme mass ratio inspirals) especially
during the design phase. Also a number of nearby WD-WD systems will be
resolved with LISA, presenting a great potential for testing our models
of common envelope evolution or a number of issues (e.g., tidal heating)
involved in WD-WD mass transfer calculations.
I initiated comprehensive theoretical studies of the white dwarf
populations, and the first results have been already obtained [3]. The next
set of results is coming in a near future (Ruiter et al., in preparation).
Investigations of black hole populations in young cluster environments are
also underway. So far we only presented the results which can serve as the
initial input for detailed dynamical studies of dense cluster environments
[4,22]. However, we will also present follow up studies with full
dynamical interactions (Sadowski et al., in preparation). These studies are
targeted to address a number of interesting issues connected with the combined
effects of stellar evolution and dynamics in clusters (e.g., enhanced
cluster formation of XRBs, or intermediate-mass BH formation).
The first population metal-free stars (Pop III) have attracted a great deal
of interest since they are believed to be responsible for re-ionization and
metal enrichment in the early Universe. Additionally, they can also form (due to
their initial high mass and lack of mass loss) massive BH remnants
(≥ 100 M sun). These intermediate mass BHs may have played a
crucial role in forming todays supermassive BHs. I plan on performing detailed
modeling of the evolution of the first stars with a special emphasis on massive
BH formation. Evolutionary consequences include GR signals [17] and
high-redshift GRBs.
For references see my List of Publications.
|